| Stenhousemuir 2 - 0 (0-0) Arbroath |
| Arbroath 1 - 0 (1-0) Stenhousemuir |
| Stenhousemuir 2 - 1 (0-0) Arbroath |
| Arbroath 0 - 2 (0-1) Stenhousemuir |
| Stenhousemuir 1 - 4 (1-2) Arbroath |
| Arbroath 5 - 2 (2-1) Stenhousemuir |
| Stenhousemuir 1 - 2 (1-0) Arbroath |
| Stenhousemuir 2 - 2 (1-1) Arbroath |
| Arbroath 2 - 1 (1-1) Stenhousemuir |
| Stenhousemuir 3 - 2 (0-0) Arbroath |
| Arbroath 3 - 4 (1-1) Stenhousemuir |
| Stenhousemuir 2 - 2 (1-2) Arbroath |
| Arbroath 0 - 0 (0-0) Stenhousemuir |
| Stenhousemuir 1 - 0 (1-0) Arbroath |
| Arbroath 2 - 2 (1-1) Stenhousemuir |